In the makeup world, mascara is a game-changer—notably as we age. “The one” can lift, lengthen, and add definition, bringing a youthful sparkle back to your eyes.
Yet you may be bewildered by a million options available, and you’re not alone. I am here to help you pinpoint the best mascara for older women with the magic to boost your inherent beauty without clumping, smudging, or weighing down your lashes. Embark on the journey for a new go-to for a fresh, radiant look!
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through my links, at no cost to you.
10 Best Mascara For Older Women: Can’t Ignore!
#1 L’Oréal Paris Voluminous
Regarding the best mascara for older women, get panoramic lash volume from corner to corner with the Voluminous Panorama one! The lightweight, long-lasting formula delivers fanned-out lashes, rendering your eyes up to 1.4x bigger.
The multi-level bristle brush grabs each lash from inner to outer corners for even application from root to tip, based on the 5% stretch flex complex formula.
I find it also “wowed” with its formula of smudge-resistant, clump-resistant, and flake-resistant lashes with up to 24-hour wear. It also fits sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers without hesitation.
Pros
- Fanned-out lashes
- Bristle brush
- Epic smudge-resistant formula
- Appropriate for sensitive eyes or ones with contact lenses
Cons
- A bit hard to clean up entirely
- Maybe way too wet so you must be careful
- Still have some chunks left on lashes after washing
#2 L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Volume Mascara
Here’s another gem from L’Oréal with over 24,000 reviewers, boasting a solid 4.4-star rating! I’m featuring the waterproof version. It doesn’t clump like so many others I’ve ever tried. Plus, it stays put for hours, and that’s all I want – a versatile mascara!
With this incredible mascara, you can now try an instant lash lift effect for iconic volume, length, and lift. Infused with fibers, it delivers a stunning false eyelash effect without requiring pricey procedures.
Of note, the double-curved brush and fiber-infused formula work together to grab your lashes right at the root, lifting, thickening, and lengthening them. Time to say goodbye to clumps, smears, and flakes all day long!
What’s more, I can easily have subtle lines, smoky vibes, or a pop of color. Also, the brand’s eyeshadow, eyeliner, brow, and mascara collections have got you covered.
Pros
- Flexible to create incredible outlook
- Double-curved brush and fiber-infused formula available
- Washable and easy to clean
- Easy to use
Cons
- May fade swiftly and not easy to be as-is all day long.
#3 L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Makeup Lash Paradise Mascara
It’s time to flaunt a feather-soft lash fringe with zero flaking, smudging, or clumping—just pure, voluptuous volume and intense length.
The top-tier mascaras and primers will satisfy your desire for dramatic volume or exquisite length.
Another thing I love is spicing my eyes up with this Voluminous mascara collection, smudge-proof eyeliners, and dashingly defining brow products with shadow palettes and crafted shades for vibrant eyes!
With a fade-proof color lasting up to 16 hours, your look will stay sharp and on point all day. At L’Oreal Paris, you deserve nothing less than perfection!
Pros
- Soft wavy bristle brush available
- 20x more volume, and up to 20x more length
- Smooth glide formula
- Water-proof and cry-proof
Cons
- May sometimes have curl falls after a few use hours
#4 ILIA – Limitless Lash Mascara
I tried every brand, from high-end to drugstore, and no matter what, within hours, I ended up with mascara smudged all over my face. Waterproof? 24-hour wear?
For years, I stuck to one brand that stayed out—until they changed the formula, and boom, raccoon eyes again.
I went on a frantic search for a new holy grail, mascara. I stumbled upon this one, which is highly rated but not labeled waterproof. I didn’t believe the smudge-proof claims… until I tried it.
Let me tell you, this mascara makes the difference! After a full 12-hour day, my lashes still look fresh, long, and natural. No raccoon eyes, just beautiful, smudge-free lashes! Plus, it’s affordable and packed with natural ingredients—double win! ILIA, you’ve got a customer for life. Please never change your formula and brighten it!
Pros
- Non-toxic
- Safe for sensitive eyes
- Lightweight and comfortable
- Flake and smudge-resistant
Cons
- The smell may not be good at large
- Not very great for super-watery eyes as this is not waterproof
#5 Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
This product lives up to the hype, creating a bold, false-lash-worthy outlook without the struggle of fake lashes.
Indeed, after a few coats only, your aged lashes looked longer, fuller defined—no clumping or flaking. Its brush is dreamy too, leaving every lash perfect for a bold, voluminous look that stays all day.
Whether it’s a long workday or a night out, this mascara keeps its stable intensity. And despite the all-day wear, it’s surprisingly easy to remove – No smudging or fading, even in humidity. How about the overall result? A head-to-toe confidence boost!
Pros
- Long-lasting effect
- No clumping or flaking throughout the day
Cons
- Not water-proof
- May wear off after about 8 hours, needing either to re-curl the lashes or provide another coat after the workday.
- It has a subtle chemical smell
#6 CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara Makeup
It’s time to get the ultimate big-lash look! This powerhouse formula amps up the lashes to a tee, instantly delivering times more volume than bare lashes. For extra pop, pair it with Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner for flawless contrast with brighter and evener eyes than ever.
I bet that it can’t be clumped and washed off easily. It’s pretty stable and long-lasting, with epic color and coverage. Granted, be careful, as the waterproof and not waterproof packaging looks identical.
Pros
- Top-rated products
- Natural look
- Washes off easily
- Cruelty-free ingredients
Cons
- Some Amazon reviewers say they received dried-out product
#7 Honest Beauty 2-in-1 Extreme Length Clean Mascara
Ready to level up your skincare game? Honest Beauty offers cruelty-free mascara coupled with natural ingredients and even includes a primer. Your conscience will thank you!
I think I’ve found my holy grail mascara – the best mascara for older women! For lashes that are teeny-tiny, super straight, and invisible without mascara, finding one for a look lush is a challenge. Yet Honest Beauty Co.’s option will change the game for those ladies.
The lashes instantly doubled in length, no clumping, just outstandingly separated lashes. After about 20 seconds, apply the coal-black mascara, and bam—instant fabulous lashes! No flaking, no smudging, even after hours of dancing or working out, and your lashes still look fresh all day long.
Though it’s not cry-proof, it’s easy to remove without pulling out lashes. Bonus points for being allergy-friendly! As someone with celiac disease and multiple allergies, finding products I can use is a struggle, but this one’s a breadwinner. It doesn’t smudge on my bottom lashes! After years of avoiding bottom-lash mascara because of smudging, I can finally rock the full-lash look again!
Pros
- Super easy to remove without pulling out your lashes
- Allergy-friendly
- Doesn’t smudge on my bottom lashes
Cons
- Not cry-proof
- In scorching hot weather, the mascara tends to run a bit
#8 Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara
Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara gives your lashes the love they deserve, making them beautifully long and healthy. Enriched with vitamin E and olive oil, this unique formula nourishes and strengthens your lashes from within, keeping them solid and stunning day after day.
The gentle bristle brush effortlessly glides through each lash, delivering antioxidant-rich color for a bold, intensified look. Forget about clumps, flaking, and smudging—just flawless, 100% longer lashes!
Achieve fuller, longer lashes with Neutrogena Mascara! This tube contains antioxidant vitamin E, rice protein, and olive oil to nourish and fortify your lashes, helping them reach their full potential—up to 100% longer!
The clump-free, smudge-proof formula applies smoothly, while the soft-bristle brush defines every lash from root to tip for a flawless, intense finish. Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, this dermatologist- and ophthalmologist-tested mascara is easy to remove with Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover or just soap and water.
Pros
- Have nutrients good for your lash nourishing
- Clump-free, smudge-proof formula
- Soft-bristle brush defines every lash from root to tip
- Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
Cons
- May run on the dry side and flake after afternoon
#9 PrimeLash Mascara for Older Women
Say farewell to lash woes! Meet PrimeLash Mascara, crafted with the wisdom of 1,200 fabulous mature queens for a clump-free, hypoallergenic wonder for your sensitive eyes.
Get lashes stealing the spotlight and rendering you feel like a million bucks, all thanks to a dreamy wand paired with a powerhouse formula. This wand effortlessly combs and separates even the finest lashes—no clumps, smudges, or eye bruises. Plus, it’s hand-tremor friendly for top-tier applications!
Infused with lash-loving nutrients, this boosts growth and keeps your lashes nourished, non-drying, and clean.
As we age, lashes may thin and shorten, but PrimeLash mascara swoops in to give you jaw-dropping length and volume in just two coats, strengthening your natural lashes. Easy removal, zero breakage—as your lashes deserve the optimum!
Pros
- Natural elements
- pH-balanced formula
- Gentle and lashes-friendly
- Non-drying
- Smudge-proof and smear-proof
- Vegan
- Cruelty-free
Cons
- May dry out quite fast
#10 Tower 28 MakeWaves Vegan Mascara
The last in the best mascara for older women list – this mascara is go-to for those who love layering multiple coats. “It makes lashes fluffy and super buildable. Plus, it washes off easily,” she says.
What reviewers are raving about: “I’ve tried every drugstore mascara out there, searching for one that doesn’t leave me with raccoon eyes by noon. This is the one! It stays put, looks amazing, and removes effortlessly with makeup remover. Please never stop making it!”
Get bold, natural-looking lashes with our black mascara that delivers noticeable volume, length, and definition. Lightweight and endlessly buildable, it layers without flaking, clumping, or crunching.
Our unique wand features three flexible bands that grab and define every lash for primary length and boldness. Powered by Aquaflex Technology, usually found in haircare, it keeps your lashes lifted, volumized, and humidity-proof.
Ophthalmologist-tested and contact lens-safe, this non-clumping mascara easily washes off, preventing irritation and breakage.
Our vegan mascara is gentle enough for sensitive skin yet powerful enough for everyone. It’s clean, cruelty-free, and free from irritants.
Use the inner curve of the brush to build volume and the longer bristles to lengthen and define. Add more coats while your lashes are still wet for an extra boost!
We’re committed to the planet! MakeWaves comes in packaging made from 78% post-consumer recycled plastic.
Pros
- Stays put
- Easy to remove
- Buildable
Cons
- Some reviewers found the formula clumpy
Go-to Mascara Tips and Magical Tools For Optimal-Looking Aged Lashes
Catch the most vibrant and iconic eye beauty with these tip-top options:
Eyelash Curler
Give your lashes a top-rated eyelash curler before swiping on your mascara for a flawless lift and curl. Once you use one, you will be “wowed” with the stunning look!
Eyelash Comb
The trusty eyelash comb will “wow” you in making a bold turn and so much safer than the old-school safety pin trick.
Essence Volume Booster Lash Primer
Ever given an eyelash primer a go? It’s like a secret weapon to the perfect base for mascara. Just apply it and move on to another part of your hair or makeup routine while it dries.
Mascaras for Mature Eyes: What You Need to Know
Eye Sensitivity
As we age, we often experience increased eye sensitivity, dryness, and even blurry vision—thanks to hormonal shifts like menopause. Our eyes become more prone to irritation over time, so getting allergy-tested and safe products for sensitive eyes is key.
Plus, with mature eyes that tear, opting for a long-lasting formula is vital. Tubing mascaras are smudge-proof and breeze to remove, making them perfect for keeping eyeliner and mascara in place all day.
Moisturizing Ingredients
Like hair, lashes can thin and become sparser with age. You should seek items with conditioning ingredients like keratin, shea butter, and beeswax. Another favorite was Tarte’s Tartelette Tubing Mascara, packed with shea butter and castor oil for extra nourishment.
Shade Selection
When it comes to color, opt for brown mascaras over black for a softer, more flattering look on mature eyes. Brown or black-brown shades are sparkling and suitable for special occasions.
How To Choose The Best Mascara For Mature Women
When choosing the best mascara for older women, some experts recommend considering the following:
Our eyelids may droop and contact our lashes more frequently as we age. Pros advise picking a long-wearing formula to prevent smudging and transfer throughout the day.
As we age, our hair and lashes can lose luster. Opt for a mascara that nourishes your lashes and adds shine. While waterproof mascaras might seem ideal for watery eyes, experts caution that they can be hard to remove. He suggests reserving waterproof formulas for special occasions.
Mascaras labeled “hypoallergenic” or “fragrance-free” are great for sensitive eyes; you should also avoid potential irritants like parabens, sulfates, and formaldehyde.
FAQs
What Are Eyelash Problems On Older Women Faces?
Aging comes with changes in hair density and texture and eyelashes as well. Eyelash issues that occur in old ladies may include:
- Thinning: Older women may first face eyelash thinning as a typical aging-related sign.
- Turning brittle: The eyelashes will become brittle as you age, raising the likelihood of higher breakage.
- Graying: The eyelashes get gray alongside the hair changes.
- Slower regrowth: The eyelash begins to slow down, resulting in fewer lashes and long-lasting regrowth progress.
Should An Older Woman Wear Mascara On Bottom Lashes?
Yes, but with caution. There’s no hard-and-fast rule against wearing mascara on your bottom-aged lashes, but applying it with a light hand is wise.
Don’t let a heavy coat of mascara emphasize fine lines with a droopy effect. Go for a subtle application that enhances your eyes without overwhelming them, keeping your look fresh and youthful.
How Do You Keep Mascara From Creasing Under Your Eyes?
Here grasps all 6 steps for halting your mascara from flaking or smudging:
- Cleanse the face and lashes
- Apply a primer
- Use a tri-locking mascara
- Lightly dust under the eyes — never bake
- (Occasionally) wipe your undereyes.
- Apply mascara correctly
How Many Coats Of Mascara Is Best?
Less is more—going overboard can lead to flaking. Just stick to 1-3 coats for lashes that look naturally full or dramatically bold, all day long.
How Often Should I Replace My Mascara?
To keep your eyes safe and your lashes looking sparkling and dashing, it’s essential to swap out your mascara every 3-6 months—even if you haven’t hit the bottom of the tube. Mascara can become a hotspot for bacteria, leaving eye infections and other pesky issues.
Each time you use the mascara wand, bacteria can pick up from the skin around your eyes and transfer it back into the tube, where it multiplies.
Plus, as mascara ages, it tends to dry out and clump, making it harder to apply seamlessly and giving you less-than-stellar results.
So, to keep your mascara fresh and your lashes on point, try to replace it regularly, even if that means parting with a half-used tube.
Why Does Mascara For 20-Year-Olds Not Work on Your Mature Lashes?
Mascaras designed for twenty-somethings tend to be bold, dark, and long-lasting—but they might not be the best fit for more mature lashes. Here’s why:
- They often have fragrances and parabens that may irritate sensitive skin and cause allergic reactions.
- Their waterproof formulas dry out your lashes and flake off onto your upper lid or even cheeks.
- The wands are usually too big to handle fine, delicate lashes, resulting in clumps that can look less than flattering.
- Regarding removal, these mascaras can be a real hassle, taking a toll on the aged lashes over a while.
Wrapping Up
And there you have it—the ultimate roundup of mascaras catering to the beauty and needs of older ladies!
Whether you’re aiming for luscious length, voluminous drama, or a natural, defined outlook, these mascaras are your ticket to eye-catching lashes and thus your timeless beauty.
Remember, age is just a number, and with the right mascara, your eyes will shine anyway. So go ahead, flutter those drop-dead lashes and embrace the confidence coming with finding the best mascara for older women!